I have some conjectures, clues, theories etc. that I want to follow, but these are the things that researchers look to solve. It is not what you are probably interested in listening to me theorize about. So, rather than go into any more of this, when I actually get something concrete about these neighbors and other settlers if they pertain to James Sr. and John Sr. and where they came from or any other related persons, then I will share it.
For now, back to the family that we do know. We have already commented on what we know about James Sr., and Elizabeth including family tradition that has been passed down but not proved. I will add one more piece of information here. When I first began, the oldest living relative at the time that I could ask for information was Uncle Louis LaRue of Osceola, Wisconsin. He gave me bunches, and so far none of it has proven in error. (Not something that the other old timers who shared with me can claim.) Anyhow, his daughter Marilyn states that her dad had always said that the LaRues had a German back ground. I am guessing that Louis in talking to grand parents as he grew up was able to glean bits and pieces of family history that others never got. And, so far, in all my research of the LaRues and the female collateral lines that married into LaRues, I have not found anything that looks like a German name so far. But, names were adapted to look more American over time. So, where a line originated cannot always be determine from their name. In fact, when our LaRue Huguenot ancestors left France, many of them went into Protestant countries like England, Switzerland, Germany and Holland. Those last 3 countries were at one time part of a German Empire or spoke German or were called Deutsch aka German. So, another clue?
Also, Elizabeth Jordan has been offered as a daughter of Patrick aka Peter Jordan born in Ireland and his wife Elizabeth or Mary Shull who was born in Germany. There has been no definitive proof of this parentage yet. But it is interesting to note. And, this Jordan line had the father and sons participating in the Revolutionary War and some of them then migrated from Loudon County, Virginia up into the SW corner of Pennsylvania and eventually into Belmont, Guernsey and Noble County area. Right in the neighborhood where James Sr. is living. Is this the route that James Sr. took into Ohio? Is this the people he traveled with, his wife's people? Is this the source of the German background offered into the family line? This Patrick Jordan names all his sons when he leaves land and inheritance to them but no daughter Elizabeth. Could this mean that he had no daughter Elizabeth OR that he had already given her and her husband her inheritance already? Interesting to speculate, and maybe as we find more records, I will find more information that will clear this up.
There is another line of LaRue/Larews out of an Abraham Larew and his wife Abigail Rittenhouse. They had couple of children who married in the Guernsey County area and some remained a number of years in that vicinity. I won't confuse you with all their names, but they went from Virginia into the SW corner of Pennsylvania before migrating into the SE corner of Ohio, where we find James Sr. and his family. This line of Larew does have the name of William passed down in it. A coincidence? The route they took was similar to the Jordan family but it was similar to a LOT of people migrating West.
I am convinced that the naming of James Sr.'s children is indicative of his family and his wife's family. Naming children after honored family members was exceeding common and I simply feel that the names of their children provide clues. But, I will not consider them evidence. The use of the name Charity is not a common name among the Abraham group, nor is David or Laban. There is a Charity Larew who married a Jacob Rockefeller who would have been of the same general age of James Sr. Is she someone related? There are other names that James uses for his children that are interesting. But what is most interesting is the names that he does not use. He does not use the names of Abraham, Isaac,Jacob, Peter, nor Jabez. Some of these names are faithfully passed down by some Larue clans. But, not ours. Ever!
So, back to the children of James Sr. and Elizabeth. We have in order (as we know them) Sarah, Charity, William, Permelia, John, Margaret, James, Laban, David, unknown male, and Eliza Ellen.